Forgetting Sarah Marshall
Mr. Cranky's rating:
I guessed at this point that Peter was into having girls shit on his face since that was about the only way either one of these hotties was going to go near the dude.
Seems to me critics have been falling all over themselves to praise this awkward film written by "How I Met Your Mother" star Jason Segel and part of that whole Judd Apatow production juggernaut that is taking over the world. Me, not so much.
Because Apatow doesn't have time to direct every new, R-rated, raunchy post-post Porky's cinematic achievement, he's farmed such duties out to his friends as a sort of training exercise. This one is directed by Nicholas Stoller, whose qualifications for directing a feature are a couple episodes of "Undeclared". Now, I suppose this is perfectly good experience, but pretty much a scene didn't go by where I was wondering if Stoller was playing with the camera or masturbating or doing something other than paying attention to what was going on.
The pregnant pause is a perfectly adequate mechanism for creating a sense of awkwardness. However, when those pauses seem to come one, right after another, it's more a sign of laziness. I mean, fine, if I'm having a conversation with somebody who's verbally challenged, I get that things might progress slowly. When I go see a movie, there's just no reason to drag things out. "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" is a movie that you'll be able to put on 2x when it comes out on DVD and not notice a thing.
And for anybody who's heard anything about this movie, I'm obviously avoiding what most of you would have expected to be my lead, which is that viewers are treated to the site of Jason Segel's penis about three thousand times. Seriously, you look down, you look up. There's Segel's penis. You get up and go to the bathroom and come back. There's Segel's penis. I spend enough of my time looking away from male genitalia in the gym. I don't need more of it in the theater.
And am I really supposed to believe that Peter Bretter (Jason Segel) can bed both Sarah Marshall (Kristen Bell) and Rachel Jansen (Mila Kunis)? Give me a break. Sarah, a television star, dumps Peter. Peter goes to Hawaii for some relaxation, runs into Sarah with her new rock-and-roll boyfriend, Aldous Snow (Russell Brand), and falls for Rachel. I guessed at this point that Peter was into having girls shit on his face since that was about the only way either one of these hotties was going to go near the dude. Segel's penis certainly wasn't the explanation.
For those of you who've been here awhile, I refer you to my "Forget Paris" review as my parting line for "Forgetting Sarah Marshall". Yes, I know, self referencing is disgusting, but sometimes such things are apropos.
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "Forgetting Sarah Marshall" forum
Messages:
Congrats Barbara...you're a slut... Hamartoma
Aww....Ling Ling died!!! Hamartoma
DNA confirms bone fragments are czar's children Mal_Content
Workers of the World, Unite! Wallee_Pipps
The Democrats are just devastated X-Man
Fat Chick Goes For Miss England. DarthGaul
Lou Dobbs on Bush Oddball
Crankyland killfile still doesn't work X-Man
Which song would you choose as the greatest '80s power ballad? Mal_Content
A song for Rajah TMundo
Explanation for Paula Hamartoma
Just watched "Diary of the Dead".. Drew_Atreides
Mal, here's a review of "Iron Man" Rajah
Disney's Goofey + David Lynch = Funny Funny Funny... TMundo
Apologies if the left gets mad jwilson07
My first amendment rights Hamartoma
Albert Hofman dies at age 102 Spanky
Amuse me, Goddammit! Wulfgar
Jimmy Carter 'endorses' Obama Hamartoma
Bush approval rating on the economy reaches a record low Oddball
London Times - Top 100 Films Spanky
U.S. Supreme Court says requiring voter ID is OK. I agree, here's why. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Who needs Indiana Jones when you can have a cheap DTV knockoff? M_H
Who is going to see "Iron Man" this weekend? Mal_Content
CFL! Gary Coleman married a white woman half his age and twice his height! Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Interesting recent court ruling. the_demon
Rev Wright may be trying to sink Obama Dan_in_Cincinnati
Comments on New Home Page Feature Mr_Cranky
Anyone stimulated yet? the_demon
Any Crankyites going to Jazz Fest? nickumoh
National Treasure 2: Book of Stupid Coaster
CRANKYLAND POLL : Best and Worse Lines From Movies Rajah
Deathwatch, minutes until obama has wright beaten to death. jwilson07
Anybody else here hooked on The Office? Oddball
McCain's position on Iraq has completely flip-flopped since 2005 Oddball
LOST CAUSE DarthGaul
Leaked new DARK KNIGHT trailer (not so great quality) MR_MUCUS
Help, I think I've caught Rajah's MCD!!!!!!!!!!!!! TMundo
Holy Experimantal 80's Batman!!!! This stuff is wild... TMundo
Does famine correlate to population density, corruption, both, or neither? Captain_Lance_Murdoch
I would be very mad if I was a democrat still. jwilson07
Row over Sheperd's Pie Ends in Court Ickyru
This rocks Critico
So why exactly is Miley Cyrus apologizing for that photo spread? The_Third_Nipple
Amy Addams : Yeah, you know what I wanna do to her! Rajah
POLL: Best Concert Ever Poll Terribella
Thoughts on recently-seen movies <PERHAPS MINOR SPOILERS> HomeSkillet
'Baby Mama' delivers $18.3 million at box office Mal_Content
More NeoCon Stuff...Enjoy! STIR THE POT! DarthGaul
I rented "There Will Be Blood". Mal_Content
Forgetting Sarah, U. S. Marshalls MR_MUCUS
Make your own Judd Apatow movie Spanky
Craig Ferguson very funny Spanky
"Undercover Brother" is actually pretty funny Xur
Woman claims father held her in cellar for 24 years Mal_Content
A Republican candidate in Indiana leads the way! Oddball
McCain's campaign receives corporate welfare...from McCain's wife Oddball
steyn tanstaafl
Now that all the ancient ones are gone... Junk_Yard_Dog
WHO WILL I PISS OFF THE MOST WITH THIS POST? DarthGaul
SCIENTOLOGY DEFEAT! DarthGaul
POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL POLL DarthGaul
no media bias here, nope nope nope jwilson07
Oh, I looked up penn war dead in Iraq. jwilson07
Mentions: "Iraq caulties"=1; "war in Iraq=1; and "died in Iraq"=1 Coaster
so you rather fight them in oklahoma? jwilson07
"Im Not Afraid Of Al Qaeda, Im Afraid of Al CRACKER" DarthGaul
and if we follow your liberal logic jwilson07
4000 dead is a tradgedy and must be stopped no matter the cost jwilson07
30 million babies dead is a punchline over wine and cheese. jwilson07
thats liberal logic at its BEST! jwilson07
Tighten the border, dump cash into the CIA and FBI DarthGaul
actually it did help the romans jwilson07
So, how's the search for Osama Bin Laden going? M_H
Yeah all them rebellions were part of the plan right? DarthGaul
AND WHAT THE HELL ARE YOU DOING UP AT THIS HOUR? DarthGaul
Somehow... Junk_Yard_Dog
JYD has some valid points, and some rather silly jwilson07
just curious mh, how many attacks on US soil since 9-11? jwilson07
darth, do you mean the celts jwilson07
Well, it was 8 years between the 2 WTC attacks... M_H
Yeah Thats Who I Mean.. DarthGaul
And If You Are So Keen To Keep The Fight Over There.. DarthGaul
My nephew, a Philadelphia native, is currently stationed in Kurdistan Wallee_Pipps
Talking about a nation suppressing a native people... Junk_Yard_Dog
no pleasing liberals jwilson07
The Japs Put Egg In Everything. DarthGaul
Yuck!!!!!!!!!!!! Junk_Yard_Dog
Eggs are disgusting. Wulfgar
Question, please: What's the link to the updated killfile? Oddball
$300,000 watch that doesn't tell time Mal_Content
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Reality check, corporations pass along a tax to you. jwilson07
Donnie Darko michael3b
Supreme Court michael3b
My dad...PETA's best friend. Omega_Man
You could have a steam train Rajah
EARTH DAY SENSE.... DarthGaul
THE KETCHUP RANT! DarthGaul
Human Beings Facing Extinction! Rajah
Comedian says obvious billboard messages, I say, heres a few of my own... TMundo
I just got a Wii. Mal_Content
One of the most ignorant rap songs ever made TMundo
the forum TMundo
Strange growing up in the same household Hamartoma
There was a handle called "Dick_Stroker"? Hamartoma
Does anyone in this country really have a dog in this fight? Hamartoma
On the plus side, the ring-wingers have been playing nice today... M_H
Well..... Hamartoma
That flame war would be over before the crowd had even taken their seats. Throwing_Muses
I thought you guys were the moral and righteous? Hamartoma
last night, even w/ the killfile I could tell some threats had been fired.. TMundo
What's strange is... Junk_Yard_Dog
the thing about grundle though... TMundo
I vow to be more like grundle Rajah
evry1z mizng teh pnoitez. TMundo
You know what gives me pause, Mr. T? Coaster
pause? TMundo
I would like to mention something jwilson07
It's too bad the left-wingers never play nice on this forum X-Man
^^Wau! Wau! Mommy! Mommy! They're picking on me!!! Wauhhhhhh!!!! Throwing_Muses
Xie Junk_Yard_Dog
No, Mr. Dog. Coaster
Hmm, sounds like I missed some fun this week Xur
jwilson... Mal_Content
mal, is if then jwilson07
So Mal, we'll never see you and Terribella in a mud wrestling match? Rajah
jwilson, rajah Mal_Content
Sorry, one more thing, jwilson. Mal_Content
Screw You, You Anne Murray Listening, Snow-Man Making DarthGaul
Dude. Mal_Content
Mal, you have a valid arguement jwilson07
Canadian Women Are All Ice Queens. DarthGaul
I apologize for calling Bush "chimpy" Rajah
To set the record straight... Mal_Content
The "chimpy" stuff was never really my thing... M_H
Bush *looks* like, *acts* like... Wulfgar
YIKES Wulgar!..now THATS just wrong. DarthGaul
THEN WHY WONT YOU FUCK ME MAL CONTENT? DarthGaul
^^I think you answered your own question, there, Darth.^^ Mal_Content
She goes for men in red uniforms Dudley_Do_Right
Slim Whitman? Mal_Content
Canadians love to yodel, don't they? Rajah
If You Knew Me...Mal..Youd Be Banging Me. DarthGaul
All joking aside, Darth, Mal_Content
Nice Of You To Ask.. DarthGaul
Thank you for sharing that with us! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Lets See Yours Too Barney! DarthGaul
Afraid to rent Atonement Hamartoma
Makin fun of radiohead, with a decent remake as well... TMundo
I like to think it's more legal fear Hamartoma
Lolcats 'cheezburger' site hiring bad spellers Mal_Content
OH THAT WAS BULLSHOOT CRANKY DarthGaul
scarlet and Wallee Mal_Content
Rush Limbaugh "dreaming of riots in Denver"... M_H
I think that I'm going to put random people in killfile... Wulfgar
Uhh, not to be judgemental jwilson07
San Diego shark attack - am I the only one who watches Discovery? The_Third_Nipple
he would have probably been ok..... jwilson07
I refuse to set foot in the ocean. Wulfgar
I've heard of orcas mistaking swimmers in wetsuits for seals... Mal_Content
AFAIK, there's no documented cases... Wulfgar
Naturally, I can't recall where or when I've heard of orca attacks, Mal_Content
Goddammit. Wulfgar
For every human killed by sharks, 10 million sharks are killed by humans. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
The animal that kills more U.S. citizens than any other animal is..... Captain_Lance_Murdoch
grundle, as ususal, is way off. Coaster
I thought the hippo was the world's most dangerous creature to humans. Mal_Content
You are correct, Mal Rajah
Yeah, you make fun of Peter Potamus's little pith helmet Rajah
Mal, re. Orcas HomeSkillet
No, after Jaws I never watched a movie in which a sea creature... Mal_Content
Orcas have injured or killed their trainers... Wulfgar
Note to self: cancel this summer's weekend diving trip to Catalina. HomeSkillet
Mal Content, no one in the U.S. has ever been killed by a wild hippo. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Thanks for doing my homework for me, Wulfgar! Mal_Content
How many contortionists does it take to screw in a light bulb? Coaster
Just to Be Clear Mr_Cranky
Take after grundle? Coaster
Re: Just to Be Clear Mr_Cranky
This did not need it's own thread... Slothrop
Dammit... Slothrop
Stop spamming, Sloth. Wulfgar
Stop acting idiots, you assholes! Mr_Nonsense
Dammit... Mr_Nonsense
You know, Wulfgar... Slothrop
excuse my ignorance please jwilson07
Jeez, Coaster, Nuke_Mecca
Wilson... Slothrop
So nobody's going to tell me what happened? Rajah
Ahhh yes, good times, good times... Wulfgar
thanks slothrop, i'll investigate jwilson07
Nothing happend, Rajah, NOTHING Nuke_Mecca
Hamartoma- -whatever. Nuke_Mecca
So the Mila/Kristen thread got out of control, did it? Throwing_Muses
Innocent until proven guilty Hamartoma
TREATS MR_MUCUS
TEATS... Wulfgar
Thanks Mr. Cranky! Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Thanks For What Grundle?..Censorship? DarthGaul
Thanks for the compliment about me. <nt> Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Oh... DarthGaul
Coaster Otm_Shank
My favorite part of "It's A Wonderful Life" Rajah
Ah, yes--the SNL "Director's Cut" Otm_Shank
Recent? That was like from 1986! MR_MUCUS
it was because of Coaster? Critico
Well, you could say that he threw the last punch. Mal_Content
Coaster doesn't play well with others! Barney_the_ Dinosaur
Ethanol = corporate welfare, hurts the environment, and causes famine. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Ya gotta put Eff A Gee work back in! It's the best word ever. Nuke_Mecca
So what happened? Wulfgar
So who wants to talk about movies?!?! <crickets chirp> HomeSkillet
Black Sabbath's Wikipedia entry is longer than Jesus Christ’s. Omega_Man
So much for my quadruple Firsties Hamartoma
havent seen the movie Repo
THREATS Mr_Cranky
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "Forgetting Sarah Marshall " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!