The Band's Visit (guest review)
Mr. Cranky's rating:
Oddball writes: What this proves is that no matter where you go in the world an old movie cliche isn't far away.
"The Band's Visit" tells the story of an Egyptian police band sent to play at the opening of an Arab Cultural Center in Israel. En route, the group gets confused by similar-sounding town names and gets off their bus at the wrong stop, a small, isolated dumpy town in the middle of a huge expanse of nothing.
Tension in the movie is created by the conflict between the band's leader, the embittered, pompous old fart, Tawfiq (Sasson Gabay), and the handsome, horny, rebellious young cadet, Halad (Saleh Bakri) -- read James Dean. What this proves is that no matter where you go in the world an old movie cliche isn't far away.
The landscapes in the film are so desolate that at first I thought the filmmakers had decided to make this movie on the cheap and shoot the exteriors in California's Central Valley. Frankly, if this is the Promised Land, I'm converting to Mormonism and moving to Salt Lake City. At least they have a Walmart and the beach at their dead sea isn't covered with shell casings and burned out tanks.
The band's welcome to the village is exemplified as a couple of teenagers drive up in a Volkswagen and razz the group as they are walking along the side of a desolate road. This also exemplifies a mysterious modern phenomenon: Jews driving German cars. Note to Jews: Stop driving German cars! It bugs me and I'm not even Jewish. No one should be that tolerant.
Once in town, the band meets Dina (Ronit Elkabetz), who is the sassy (i.e. obnoxious) owner of a hole-in-the wall diner. If you ever wondered what happened to Rhoda Morgenstern, she's living in a Soviet-style apartment block in a backwater hellhole in Israel.
Apparently, huck towns are the same everywhere. Outside Dina's rundown restaurant, local unemployed rubes sit, with vacant stares on their faces. Implausibly, Dina offers to house some of the stranded band members for the night, and convinces two of her bench-sitting pals to do likewise.
The rest of the film follows the awkward attempts by the Arabs and Israelis to find common ground as they share space for the night. For example, one point of plot resolution comes as the now-sentimental Tawfiq stands misty-eyed in the the doorway of Dina's bedroom watching as Halad parts Dina's Red Sea in a furious carnal act of international, multicultural understanding. Nothing will provoke tender fatherly instincts in an older man than watching a younger man banging a woman he met four hours earlier.
Balanced on the edge of the Arab-Israeli divide, yet paced like a melting glacier, this Seinfeldian movie about nothing eventually proves just that.
Wacky Academy Awards side note. "The Band's Visit" was disqualified from competing for an Oscar for Best Foreign Film, because this film, produced by Israelis, filmed by Israelis, set in Israel, and featuring an all Israeli and Arab cast had too many English words in it and, apparently, too many obtuse references to Chet Baker. There's your proof: Hollywood does hate America.
--Oddball
Was it really that bad?
You tell us! Discuss "The Band's Visit (guest review)" in the Mr. Cranky forum below!
Post a New Message in the "The Band's Visit (guest review)" forum
Messages:
Science triumphs!! Pathology of Neo-con trolls explained! Wallee_Pipps
A doctor walks into as man's office and says... TMundo
Metacritic: "88 Minutes" third worst movie EVER!!! 0b1knob
For Rajah: a touching story about hobo balls Xur
Why is the entire market in the toilet, and Google is still over $500? sonofthedummy
Lying lefties losing jobs. jwilson07
huffington post take on the debate jwilson07
The number of many beasts! The_Third_Nipple
McCain flip-flops on earmarks...in the space of one day Oddball
Cindy McCain's recipes for McCain campaign website actually stolen Oddball
Liberal Europe arrests Bridgette Bardot for speaking truth about Muslims X-Man
Rob Lowe, pedophile Democrat pervert, charged with sex harrasment by nanny X-Man
Mucus is crowding my sinuses Rajah
OK..WHO IN HERE DIGS TRANNIES? DarthGaul
I WOULD LIKE TO REITERATE MY LOVE OF ALL THINGS CONNECTED WITH POO DarthGaul
Obama in cahoots with terrorist group X-Man
Not a good night for Obama X-Man
Is the Pope the long lost cousin of Willem Dafoe in sonofthedummy
Title confirmed for new X-Files flick sonofthedummy
Darwin Award winners announced Mal_Content
Why True Christians Shouldn't Care About the Environment Rajah
For Lance Rajah
French Law: Thin Not In (great news for women) Mal_Content
Virginia Tech joke Otm_Shank
since asshat quotes ultra liberal crap jwilson07
Bush now holds record as most unpopular post-WWII president Oddball
One of McCain's advisors is a sex pervert Oddball
Did you hear about the time I visited a cannibal butcher shop in Borneo? Coaster
Crankyland Brain Trust Meeting. . . Wallee_Pipps
Democrats cause polygamy X-Man
Barack Obama the dumb negro sticks his foot in his mouth again X-Man
So when will the site be renamed to Mr Oddball.com? X-Man
Meat Eater's Poll: Favorite BBQ Style? Ickyru
Thank you, ModernRonin Wallee_Pipps
The Pope looks like a Star Wars character Spanky
I hope the movie is more entertaining than this review. Mr_Grumpy
A man walks into a doctor's office... Mal_Content
Say, Wilson Oddball
Cool parent, sell kid xbox because he refuses to do chores. Critico
Bush personally approved torture Dan_in_Cincinnati
McCain abandons veterans...again Oddball
Jimmy Carter = worst president ever Spanky
Tax code is 66,000 pages. Hillary and Obama want to add thousands more. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
R.I.P. Stanley Kamel (the psychiatrist on "Monk") <nt> Captain_Lance_Murdoch
Is John McCain the new Bob Dole? Oddball
how many primaries will the bitter speech cost hussein? jwilson07
Music Poll... Who's your favorite dead young artist? Terribella
People keep loaning me shitty movies. Mal_Content
Sorry. There is no nice way to do it. Wallee_Pipps
Yeah, either you hate what they like or reccomend something they'll hate. MR_MUCUS
I never could spell "recommend". MR_MUCUS
Mal: http://www.themoviespoiler.com/ Coaster
Try to be nice and honest. Terribella
My sister didn't like Dumb and Dumber Rajah
Then she must be killed, my friend Terribella
I've suffered through quite a few Jim Carrey movies. Wallee_Pipps
Mal, sorry you had to suffer through those. HomeSkillet
Wallee, I respectfully disagree Terribella
How would like your hair braided? Rajah
I've given up trying to talk movies with most people... Drew_Atreides
Just tell them you're a movie snob Ickyru
Let's see... Mal_Content
Shit. "Awake", not "Alive". Mal_Content
Good one, Ickyru Otm_Shank
My friends don't really buy DVDs... M_H
The only Jim Carrey movie I really liked was THE TRUMAN SHOW MR_MUCUS
Ed Harris did deserve an Oscar for Pollock Otm_Shank
Jims best work was Ace Ventura, Mal, just tell the truth... TMundo
No one can recommend RV seriously Critico
No, Critco, RV is this guy's favourite comedy. Go figure. Mal_Content
I've got a fairly good movie barometer but have friends that do not The_Third_Nipple
You didn't like "No Country for Old Men"? Mal_Content
Mal, you should watch "Eraserhead" Rajah
Mal Critico
"Hotel Rwanda" Drew_Atreides
Ok, maybe a movie like "Hotel Rwanda" isn't what you'd call enjoyable. Mal_Content
Tell your friends to insert pointless graphic sex scenes X-Man
I won't tell you about it Critico
regarding 'No Country' The_Third_Nipple
Eternal Sunshine, pretty good, No Country, lots to dig into but... TMundo
Gridlock'd TMundo
Newsweek: “McCain’s fiscal program is either a joke or a fantasy.” Oddball
URGENT CRANKYLAND POLL OF THE UTMOST IMPORTANCE!!!!! Xur
MY GUEST REVIEW: Not_LRT
Obama an elitist for picking orange juice over coffee? M_H
A 26-year-old secret could free inmate Mal_Content
Homemade sex tapes clear Republican politician charged with raping a man Oddball
liberals tanstaafl
It's like a jungle sometimes Ickyru
McCain Once Physically Attacked A Fellow Congressman Oddball
What's up with the "converts to Islam" videos on youtube. MR_MUCUS
SPOOOOOON!!! Xur
Casino Royale. HomeSkillet
Gallup poll shows Bush's approval rating at an all-time low Oddball
Here's a post I made about George W. Bush in 1999. Captain_Lance_Murdoch
'Dr. Phil' show bails out teen accused in beating Mal_Content
I think Hammy's handle has been pooched! Mal_Content
Badger Badger Rajah
I'm glad Obama didn't call me bitter Rajah
ANYBODY KNOW THE NAME OF THAT FILM DarthGaul
this weeks CSI VEGAS DarthGaul
VENDING MACHINES DarthGaul
Holy crap! Xur
Oddball, i knew most of these too jwilson07
Watched most of Peter Jackson's King Kong, I wasn't pleased... TMundo
Alrighty, might as well actually talk about movies... (poss. spoilers) M_H
More success in Iraq War Rajah
ooppsie, another one actually read the data.. jwilson07
Has anyone tried the "100-Mile Diet"... Mal_Content
High gas prices portend 'The Long Emergency' Mal_Content
'Nothing will provoke tender fatherly instincts Prime Mover
Obama's Personal Diplomacy Spells Trouble X-Man
Biofuels (liberal mandated) starving world's poor X-Man
Oddball writes another review X-Man
Mal (or anyone), have you seen 3:10 To Yuma yet? Terribella
Democrats tearing each other apart, McCain laughing on sidelines X-Man
Democrats, to save your own party.... jwilson07
Gas station run by morons sells gas for $0.35 for 9 hours... sonofthedummy
So, who's around tonight... TMundo
I'm still here, you bastards. MR_MUCUS
Now there's a movie for yah. TMundo
So...since I'm irritated and bored... MR_MUCUS
Band together with the other castoffs and create a new society... sonofthedummy
Well, that was a bit of a downer. Mal_Content
Sounds like, wait, how many people work with you, & are these people near.. TMundo
I'll take #7 for a hundred, Alex. HomeSkillet
Ha, HomeSkillet Coaster
Well, of course I'm a social retard, I mean this is the internet. MR_MUCUS
I hit it on the head... Mal_Content
Hello! Rajah
So a lady I know at work is throwing a party Coaster
misinterpretted Rajah
Well, then, Coaster, you say yes,,,then right at the last second. MR_MUCUS
That violates my work code, Mucus Coaster
So that's where that smell came from! Rajah
A knight of the old code! MR_MUCUS
I think most of us on this board are pretty much "social retards." Terribella
MR. MUCUS is a likable person Rajah
At least you aren't socialists retards...well...some of you are. Mr_Nonsense
So today, the mention it to each other when I'm around. MR_MUCUS
Well, they sound like a miserable bunch Terribella
Confirms what I've always believed Rajah
I wish they were a miserable bunch. MR_MUCUS
I don't think I'd want to belong to any group Rajah
Fishing with Vice President Cheney isn't as fun as everyone thought... sonofthedummy
saw SHINE A LIGHT in IMAX Spanky
I bought a humvee i really cannot afford... jwilson07
10 things you may not know about John McCain Dan_in_Cincinnati
Stuck in Sand Diego International with the Masters blues again. michael3b
I walked 45 miles this week. michael3b
Well kids, I've got to go... Xur
Symphony trouble - for M_H Mal_Content
Another Bushism Bush_Sucks
Fireman started blazes to earn overtime Mal_Content
God DAMN I love Internet radio... Xur
'Zombie Strippers' - crazy idea or genius film making? The_Third_Nipple
Darth Gaul, allow me to BLOW YOUR MIND Xur
The Band's Visit? Otm_Shank
1700 Posts..As Of.... DarthGaul
Kobe Bryant jumps over speeding car (is this real?) Rajah
Thinking of taking a break... M_H
If you're leaving I'm leaving too! Rajah
You have my full support and understanding, M_H Terribella
^^^There ain't no sunshine when you're gone Rajah
I cant help but think the same way sometimes. DarthGaul
The post count reflects... Rajah
Re: Thinking of taking a break... Junk_Yard_Dog
M_H, if you leave, that means the trolls have won Coaster
One thing I do not understand The_Third_Nipple
Don't leave y'all! Xur
TTN Xur
sorry you feel that way jwilson07
just for the record jwilson07
fyi tanstaafl
yeah, but... michael3b
No thanks Xur
Freep, and they're *dumber*, to boot. Wulfgar
mikey hates bush, stop the presses. jwilson07
I'm thinking of leaving, too Otm_Shank
M_H Mal_Content
Xur Mal_Content
I can't believe I just wrote "slog through the slag". Mal_Content
Thanks Mal Xur
Oops Xur
Don't leave, M_H! HomeSkillet
M H, you and I always got along real well! <nt> Captain_Lance_Murdoch
(gives breasts a gentle squeeze...) Mal_Content
One more thing, M_H, Mal_Content
if M_H leaves... michael3b
Heh. Mal_Content
Crankyland is where we come to be silly Rajah
The Killfile is your friend lost_cause
Once the lone voice of reason fixes the kink, everyone should download it. TMundo
Thanks, M_H Ickyru
Bush Sucks/politic shit ruined the board years ago. MR_MUCUS
It's not the political crap that ruined it... lost_cause
AHAHAHA, what a fucking clown X-Man
Terribella X-Man
Awww, this thread has sent my lips a quivering Terribella
Xie... Junk_Yard_Dog
One Terribella post is worth a million X-Man posts Rajah
Thanks everyone... M_H
Speaking of which.... Rajah
CRANKYLAND IS EMPTY WITHOUT ME: Not_LRT
Coaster wants to meat you someday Rajah
ONCE AGAIN..WHAT WAS LAST WEEKS FILM?..and GLOBAL WARMING IS BULLSHIT DarthGaul
Bush announces end to troop drawdown, cuts tours back to 1 year.... sonofthedummy
Just when you though it was safe to give to charity.... sonofthedummy
One person thread... MR_MUCUS
Stephen King's the Band's VisIt MR_MUCUS
The Band's Firsties MR_MUCUS
If you just posted, hit "reload" on your Web browser to see your comments.
Mr. Cranky's Archives
Mr. Cranky's Home Page
Shopping with Mr. Cranky! Earn us operating funds
with every purchase begun from these links!
Get your "The Band's Visit (guest review) " stuff here!
We earn 5% on every purchase!
DVD
VHS
Soundtrack
Book
Poster
Start all your online shopping trips from the links below and help us live another day! We earn:
5% on all purchases!
25% on all purchases!
5-10% on all purchases!
$9 for new sign-ups!
Mr. Cranky Gear
Mr. Cranky shirts! Caps! And mugs! All at Mr. Cranky's new Cafe Press store!